Over the last month speculations have been bubbling on YouTube about whether the musings of video-blogger lonelygirl15 were real or a staged production. This week those speculations popped.
During the summer a 16-year-old girl named Bree, home schooled with strict religious parents, and here friend Daniel, who likes Bree, became the most viewed and discussed members of the YouTube community. The series of videos were creatively edited and formed an endearing story arc that made some question their authenticity. Well, it appears the videos are part of something bigger created by a group of yet unnamed filmmakers as an art project. Now in the last week "Bree's" stuffed animals have appeared in their own spin-off series. Bloggers, news reports in New York and Los Angeles, and even Wikipedia have documented these revelations.
Now, the reason I'm bringing this up is less about the creation of these videos and more about the reaction of YouTube viewers to this discovery. They were distraught and upset. They felt foolish and deceived. They were stunned that of the millions of videos posted on YouTube some depicted fictional stories. They seemed to not want to believe this or they were not able to discern between fact and fiction. If it’s in writing, on the radio, television, or Internet it must be true. Right?
The line between entertainment and reality has become very blurred today and for many the difference is indiscernible. We are bombarded daily with commercial images that attempt to conflate fantasy with reality and opinion with fact. Filmmakers give us "docudramas" that are inspired by true events, but the facts are dramatized and fictionalized scenes are added in order to make the story more entertaining. Our televisions give us "Reality TV", which employ staffs of scriptwriters. The one-on-one "confessionals" of reality show contestants are the visual templates for the close-up videos posted on YouTube. We are so accustomed to seeing this, so it must be true. Right? Is it any wonder that so many people have difficulty discerning between fact and fiction.
This is nothing new, of course. Images are a powerful and influential part of human history. Images have been used to educate and inspire the public just as often as they have been used to deceive and manipulate. As an art history professor it should come as no surprise that I believe it is important for everyone to understand the history of images and to think critically about how they play a central role in forming our perception of the world.
Several instances from the modern era came to my mind when I first heard of the lonleygirl15 phenomenon. The first is very well known and is a classic example of how people are willing to accept as "real" information that is packaged in a format that they already are accustomed to perceiving as a factual representation. In the YouTube case this was the personal video diary. In my example it was a radio "news" broadcast. In 1938 Orson Welles broadcast a dramatization of H. G. Wells' classic The War of the Worlds. Thousands believed aliens were actually invading Earth and attacking New Jersey and New York. "The broadcast ... disrupted households, interrupted religious services, created traffic jams and clogged communications systems."
Understanding the context of who created something and why it was made is crucial to our ability to interpret its meaning. This is maybe no clearer than in the ubiquitous use and acceptance of photography to document our world. Going back a little further in history an example comes to mind that reminds us that images have always had a high level of subjectivity. In the 1870s Henry Peach Robinson created artistic photographs through combining multiple negatives to create one final image. For one of his most famous images, When the Day's Work is Done (1877), he used six negatives. The end results were very impressive. But, when he later told people how he created these photographs, they were outraged. They felt foolish and deceived. During the short history of this new medium people had come to accept photography as an objective representation of reality. Their naive innocence had been shattered.
In a similar fashion, the fans of lonleygirl15 had desired to perceive the new medium of YouTube as a reality based representation of their world. Their naive innocence has been shattered. Now with open eyes they might begin to notice how many other videos on YouTube are also created for artistic, entertainment, or commercial purposes.
The arts hold an important position in developing our understanding of the world. We must approach our surroundings with a critical eye or we may unwittingly accept anything as reality. The creative potential of YouTube has only begun to be explored by video artists, cinematographers, and performers. I believe this realization will in the end benefit all concerned.
UPDATE: Lonleygirl15, Jessica Rose, on Jay Leno, MTV and NBC News.